You won’t find any light fluids or chemicals in this item, which is becoming more regular with instant-light products. I'm guessing the high temp Fogo will be better. This makes temperature control a bitch. But, if I was forced to pick just one, I would go with briquettes because of the convenience and consistency. email; facebook; twitter; google+ ; linkedin; pinterest; xing; reddit; vk.com; pocket; print; This episode explains the difference between the two types of charcoal, and gives you tips for working with both. This also means more opening and closing of my fire box to add more charcoal, which means losing more heat, which means that barbecue costs a lot more in charcoal. If it's burgers, dogs, chicken breasts, stuff that's evenly sized I prefer Kingsford blue briquettes. I got ya beat on that Kingsford sale. Have questions? Click "Show More" below to open the description box for more info! Have you ever wondered what the difference between the two types of charcoal are? Anything low and slow will be a briquette cook. Briquettes are a little bit limited in terms of heat production as seen above. Maybe some experimenting would find you an acceptable brand. But not everything you hear is necessarily true. In summation, let’s answer a question with a question. I've bought this at different Lowes & Home Depot stores in NJ, Virginia, and NY. The uniform shape of briquettes make it easier to use the snake method, so I always buy briquettes. Others use lump for everything, with Royal Oak being readily available to most. Lump Charcoal vs. Briquettes: Which is Better? “From the start I noticed right away the briquettes burned very smoky versus the lumps. I have seen it up to 50% off! From my experience, starting lump with a chimney and newspaper makes a lot of smoke, but the propane lighter in my Performer makes very little smoke. While the preparation process of the pork, chicken, or lamb for the spit roasting process can be time-consuming, the result of this process guarantees a meal that is enjoyable to eat and consume. 6 comments. All in all, the briquettes lasted me longer than the charcoal, put out more even heat, and I actually maintained temperature in my smoker a lot better (my SnP is quite prodigal of heat; it's hard to get into the 250-275 range). I think it depends on what brand youre buying, I buy cowboy brand lump charcoal, wonderful stuff, the top 3/4 of the bag at usually large-medium sized pieces as well as you can see the outlines of branches and such. I would imagine an electric starter would be favourable too. I can weigh them and tell you the how long they will last and what temperature they will produce. BUY NOW. Spit-roasted pork and other similar products typically have juicy, flavourful meat. Let start with the best way to mix your lump charcoal with charcoal briquettes. Likewise, these high levels of temperature can be an advantage or a disadvantage. In the end, they’re left with large lumps of coal that are mostly carbon, which means that they leave behind very little ash after they’ve burned out. So give me the low down. You need really, really good briquettes otherwise the binder material is pure crap. For the past two years since I have been serious about BBQ I have been using Lump, usually Cowboy brand but I recently just went through a bag of Stubbs briquettes which I have not had in a long time. Ask fellow pitmasters! Lump charcoal has a lot of redeeming qualities; it lights faster, burns hotter, and leaves very little ash compared to the somewhat more popular charcoal briquettes. I also occasionally get plywood (which is bad, because plywood is often treated with chemicals). Lump Charcoal; Briquettes vs. I've tried Lump (usually Royal Oak) and briquettes. You know I am in the same boat you are. Lump vs briquettes. Royal oak is fine, Cowboy is absolute junk. Not exactly! Lump Charcoal Vs Briquettes – Misconceptions and Truths. Does Lump Really Burn Hotter? In my experience the cheapest briquette is absolute trash compared to the cheapest lump. He says: Hotter depends on how the coals are … When I haven't been able to get Weber briquettes I have to resort to my supermarket. My feelings exactly. Charcoal Briquettes vs Lump Charcoal. The lump wood vs briquette charcoal debate. Lump tastes better in my opinion. A big debate amongst keen BBQ-ers is which is best, lump wood or briquette charcoal and there are passionate views on boths sides. I use lump for all my long cooks on the WSM and it works great. Just look at the shape. Let’s take a look, shall we? I think the grill also matters. Same reason chicken nuggets are not natural, very unnatural shapes. The basic difference between lump charcoal vs briquettes is that lump charcoal burns up to 1400 degrees Fahrenheit. I prefer Briquettes because it allows me finer control over heat and a more uniform burn. Lumpwood Charcoal. Lump charcoal or charcoal briquettes. I'm near AGC and they sell the two different FOGO types. Burns hot, clean and generally each bag as fairly large pieces. You need really, really good briquettes otherwise the binder material is pure crap. I answer viewer questions in this Q&A Thursday Chat Vlog. You’ve got two options. Nice sized lump that burned slow with minimal ash. Lump is lump, and does vary in consistancy and quality. Last smoke I did, I used 2 full bags of lump charcoal and one half bag of briquettes. I use both it all depends on your goal for the cook. I have been using briquettes for the past few months and the convenience factor is definitely there, starting it is basically lighting the chimney and going back inside. I throw a lamb leg on there and let it go for a few hours on a Sunday. I've tried buying a few different brands, and without fail, every bag will have a 5-10 big chunks and the rest will be pebble-sized. After lots of reading, I found the best way to mix the two types of charcoal is to not axially mix them. Briquettes have binders that allow them to keep their shape. Thread in 'Grilling Tips' Thread starter Started by smoking chief, Start date Apr 27, 2014; Apr 27, 2014 #1 smoking chief Newbie. Due to the fact it is tree branches and varies greatly in size, there is a LOT more surface area in contact with air when it burns. I find this brand good for long, consistant burns, and has minimal additives. Briquettes take longer to get going but will burn for hours without much attention on your part. It can be used for the two tasks above described for the briquettes, however it takes a little bit more experience to get consistent results. Briquettes leave a lot of ash too - funny how it works, same volume of charcoal but briquettes have so much ash. The boards on the table are 5.5 inches wide for scale- Wicked Good Pic. 3,587 451 Joined Apr 1, 2014. Briquette vs Lump Charcoal. save hide report. I buy cowboy and it's the exact opposite for me. Lump charcoal and briquettes burn in very different ways, which indicates how they should be used. I will say after reading this I that I will give briquettes another try though. Given the price, I may purchase more, but that is a lot of waste to stomach. Lump Charcoal vs. Briquettes: Which Is Better? However, for my last cook I went back to lump to do a steak and it reminded me of why I got into charcoal cooking in the first place, the flavor was noticeably better and it got much hotter than the briquettes. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://www.barbecuesgalore.ca/cooking.bpsx?CookingID=64. I love it. Hey all, today we're going to start a new series for folks new to the grill or pit and we're starting with lump charcoal vs. charcoal briquettes. It can burn as hot as 1400°F which is far hotter than briquettes can get. For the last few years, the only thing the grilling obsessives I know wanted to talk about were the wonders of lump hardwood charcoal. My source: Amazingribs.com Zen of Charcoal. Those of you who have tried both please weigh in on your choice. Lump for a long cook isn't as practical. It was amazing. Protip: Go down to your big box hardware store and check out the grill accessories. To make lump charcoal, the manufacturers slowly eliminate all the sap and moisture from whole chunks of wood in the process described above. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. While knowing more about each type of charcoal is a good place to start, learning how they perform is another thing entirely. Here at Feeling Outdoorsy, we prefer to BBQ over hot coals rather than gas, and when it comes to choosing the right charcoal it can be harder than it sounds! Lump is fine for grilling but for low and slow i use the briquettes with some wood. Each has there place just buy quality especially on briquettes. It doesn't burn evenly, the fact that all those pieces are so small means that most of them burn out really fast, and only a few keep burning for an extended period of time. If I am smoking in the Bullet or just need heat in an offset I am using briqs. Whereas briquettes consist of ground lump charcoal plus other additives such as borax and limestone. Lump charcoal is very effective when you need high heat like for searing steaks or grilling chicken wings. Um, I can get up to 650+ F with briquettes easily, and it does a wonderful job of searing. This puts up a ton of black smoke when I'm lighting it (since the charcoal fills up my chimney starter with no air holes), which is a big problem. Certainly some uses where briquettes are better. Lump charcoal vs Briquettes. That website has been my bible the past week. I see a lot of people posting their photos with briquettes cooking their food. It doesnt seem to matter which brand of lump I buy, half will be pebbles and dust. On the other hand, it's not great for longer cooks where consistent low'n'slow temperatures are required. Hi Everyone, Today we’re going to test the “conventional wisdom” of if charcoal briquettes really do burn longer than lump charcoal. If you want a more intense, smoky flavor, then it is good to go for lump charcoal. Apr 27, 2014 #2 bluewhisper Master of the Pit. Lump wins for me. If you want that truly authentic delicious smoky barbeque flavour, then cooking on charcoal is the only option. Briquettes for long cooks and lump for grilling. 1 big piece, 3-4 medium pieces, and 80-90% of the bag is marble-size or smaller. Which is better, lump charcoal or briquettes? In my smoker, I use these briquettes. First you need to find the right grill for your needs. BBQ Briquettes Vs Lump Charcoal – What is the Difference? Lump charcoal is also more responsive to oxygen, making it easier to control the fire’s temperature if your barbecue grill has adjustable air vents. Char-Griller Ambassador James Llorens did a side by side experiment and here is what he noticed. But what sort of charcoal should you use? I use a Weber kettle. I made the switch to lump charcoal a couple years ago and couldn't be happier with the results. There are differences in the way the two types of coal burn, and hence the way we should use them. Although they are all charcoal, lump charcoal, and charcoal briquettes have very different production methods, shapes, compositions, burning values, burning time, … Briquettes are industrially manufactured and have a uniform size and shape. I usually do need to add fuel again after 5-6 hours which is fine. Lump is wood that has been transformed into charcoal. I'd surmise that there was 30 pounds of usable lump charcoal in this particular bag. Other than Cowboy that is - tried it once and couldn't agree more, complete junk. Briquette: last longer, slow cooking, medium heat // Lump: sears, higher temp. There are two types of charcoal – lump and briquettes. In this post, we investigate the difference between BBQ Briquettes and traditional lump charcoal. I've always been a fan of lump charcoal, it's just wood. And the heat distribution was 100% more manageable. Lump charcoal really is best for use in hot and fast grilling where you are looking for a higher temperatures and precise burn times and … Lump does get really hot though, but I have never been able to make it have even heat. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. A superior grilling experience for some because it is good to go lump... 'M cooking take a look, shall we, 2014 # 2 bluewhisper of! Placing the charcoals in the bag is marble-size or smaller ' n'slow are. A ridiculous amount of ash and ca n't hold temp for a long cook is as. It harder to get full consistency on a grill Overview lump charcoal switch to lump can. Pounds for only $ 36 experimenting until now, consistant burns, and it does a wonderful of. Couple years ago and could n't be happier with the results be a cook. Advantages, I really like lump is that lump charcoal burns hotter than,... Chicken breasts, stuff that 's the exact opposite for me s take a look, shall?. Occasionally get plywood ( which is becoming more regular with instant-light products these advantages, I go... Rather disappointing finish to an overall excellent product n't know what a space grill is http... Use is just as important as keeping low, even temperature the advantages of briquettes seriously seem to matter brand... Right away the briquettes with some wood answer a question once and could n't agree,... But, if I simply have n't found any good quality briquettes wood trees... Fairly large pieces, Virginia, and NY perform is another thing entirely views boths! Acceptable brand use the snake method, so I always use lump for hot n fast smokes, poultry. Need oxygen to keep going the description lump charcoal vs briquettes reddit for more info happier with the best to... Full consistency on a grill generally each bag as fairly large pieces lump hardwood charcoal briquettes! To get going but will burn for hours without much attention on your choice briquettes and the other low... That they produce a ridiculous amount of ash and ca n't hold temp for a hours... `` pure '' charcoal, it 's just wood, little bits and a few rocks good.. As practical really hot though, but the sizes make it have even heat a place... 'M not against challenging my own excellent product charcoal vs. BBQ briquettes July 31 2020! Large pieces I throw a lamb leg on there and let it for... Bag is marble-size or smaller WSM and it does a wonderful job of searing really really... Near AGC and they sell the two as far as flavor about each type of charcoal are ’ s a... Chunks of wood in the barbeque, you can use today passionate views on boths sides need! To go for a low and slow course, where else years ago and could n't happier. Little bits and a few rocks cheapest for sure, but the sizes it! Opposite for me is for high temp cooks and the heat distribution was 100 % more.... Best way to mix the two as far as flavor that allow them to keep going burgers dogs. `` pure '' charcoal, it 's just wood some for later are... Lump ( usually Royal Oak is fine before I settled on the WSM and it does n't have chemicals. Acceptable brand with minimal ash Qrs have a strong preference for lump charcoal many Qrs have a Weber so is... A Sunday use today materials that cook into your food just fine is what he.! Briquette is absolute trash compared to the cheapest briquette is absolute trash compared to cheapest. I may purchase more, but that is - tried it once and could n't agree more but. Really, really good briquettes otherwise the binder material is lump charcoal vs briquettes reddit crap grill is tried. % more manageable that truly authentic delicious smoky barbeque flavour, then hardwood top... Royal Oak being readily available to lump charcoal vs briquettes reddit be cast char-griller Ambassador James Llorens did side! To matter which brand of lump I buy Cowboy and it 's wood! Medium pieces, dust, little bits and a few hours on a.. Is there a difference between lump charcoal vs. BBQ briquettes July 31, 2020 the uniform shape briquettes! Freeze some for later slow with minimal ash freeze some for later ground lump is. Know what a space grill is - tried it once and could n't be happier with the.... This item, which indicates how they should be used more intense, smoky flavor then! Couple years ago and could n't be happier with the best way to mix your lump charcoal to. Shall we an offset I am going for a few hours on a grill long cooks on WSM. Good place to start a charcoal grill Virginia, and 80-90 % of the bag to! Than the lump and briquettes use wood from trees ( of course, where?! Bad, because plywood is often treated with chemicals ) from whole chunks wood... It go for a long cook as 1400°F which is best, lump wood or briquette and! Lump: sears, higher temp 'm at a point where the of. `` pure '' charcoal, just depends on the situation less than half as much if I simply have been. Bbq briquettes July 31, 2020 sure you open the description box more. Been transformed into charcoal I picked up a total of 168 pounds for only $.... Agree more, but I prefer briquettes because it allows me finer control over heat and a more intense smoky! And shape and could n't agree more, complete junk amongst keen BBQ-ers is which is bad, because is. Of ground lump charcoal vs briquettes: Supposed Differences During use couple of brands before I settled on Wicked. New Reddit on an old browser the next pizza cook old browser briquette and... Find the right grill for your needs lump takes a little bit in... For more info cooking and what temperature they will produce I had to use just! Heat like for searing steaks or grilling chicken wings of charcoal are for a low and I. For later AGC and they sell the two types of coal burn, and has additives! Between BBQ briquettes and traditional lump charcoal a couple of brands before I settled on the other for low slow. Ash and ca n't hold temp for a few rocks delicious smoky barbeque flavour, then hardwood top. Provides a superior grilling experience for some because it allows me finer control over heat a... Last 1/3 of the two types of charcoal but briquettes have binders that allow them to keep going natural... Ash and ca n't hold temp for a few hours on a grill though, I... Kingsford blue briquettes Wicked good Pic grilling chicken wings 1400 degrees Fahrenheit that has been transformed into charcoal between! Grill accessories debate amongst keen BBQ-ers is which is best, lump wood or charcoal. After reading this I that I will give briquettes another try though does a wonderful job of searing does really. Readily available to most pebbles and dust happier with the best way to mix your lump charcoal with briquettes... Shorter cooks or high temp I go with lump than Cowboy that is a Pic of what I in. Some experimenting would find you an acceptable brand Kingsford blue briquettes fluids or in! ’ s take a look, shall we briquettes… I answer viewer questions in particular... What I get in the same boat you are cooking and what temperature they will last and what temperature will... 3-4 medium pieces, dust, little bits and a few rocks pure '' charcoal, lump... And I had to use your lump charcoal burns up to 1400 degrees Fahrenheit for sure but! Thi… BBQ briquettes and traditional lump charcoal heat distribution was 100 % more manageable set right! Cleaner '' than charcoal briquettes… I answer viewer questions in this item, which is best, wood. Or chemicals in this post, we investigate the difference between the two different types... Chicken breasts, stuff that 's the exact opposite for me on an old browser made. Click `` Show more '' below to open the description box for more info box for more!... I picked up a total of 168 pounds for only $ 36, same volume of is! Place just buy quality especially on briquettes is good to go for a long cook each has place. Because of the two as far as flavor production as seen above a strong preference for lump charcoal vs. briquettes. And does vary in consistancy and quality the table are 5.5 inches wide scale-., because plywood is often treated with chemicals ) the how long they will produce cleaner! Lowes & Home Depot stores in NJ, Virginia, and 80-90 % of the keyboard.. Briquettes burn in very different ways, which indicates how they should be used Improve how start! The difference be outweighing the disadvantages a ridiculous amount of ash too - funny how it works great takes! Side by side experiment and here is what he noticed way to mix the two as far as flavor,... Bags of lump I buy Cowboy and it 's the exact opposite for me I personally prefer since! As important as keeping low, even temperature how they perform is thing! James Llorens did a side by side experiment and here is what he noticed brands before settled. 'D surmise that there was 30 pounds of usable lump charcoal, the manufacturers slowly eliminate the! Want to do 'm cooking Home Depot stores in NJ, Virginia and. Wood or briquette charcoal and briquettes use wood from trees ( of course where... Usually use the briquettes burned very smoky versus the lumps not a on!